beleben

die belebende Bedenkung

Half of West Coast Main Line freight paths are wasted (part two)

leave a comment »

Part one

According to the Government Response to the House of Lords Economic Affairs Committee report ‘The economics of HS2′,

[Government Response]

[2.40] In 2011 around 42 freight trains per day used the West Coast Main Line. Utilisation of intermodal freight paths is around 85%.

The source given was Network Rail’s Long Term Planning Process. However, on page 75 of the October 2013 LTPP Freight Market Study it was stated that “The Freight Market Study Working Group reviewed the path utilisation factor for intermodal flows and the Freight Market Study has used an 85 per cent figure”.

That does not mean that utilisation of West Coast intermodal freight paths is around 85%.

Table 5 of the Freight Market Study also stated that Channel Tunnel intermodal freight path utilisation was around 85%. But in reality, Channel Tunnel railfreight is a small fraction of the level which was forecast before the tunnel was built.

So, there is a great deal of obfuscation going on.

Written by beleben

August 2, 2015 at 8:11 pm

Posted in HS2

Tagged with

HS2 and economic output

with 2 comments

In a report commissioned by the Department for Transport in 2013, KPMG estimated that HS2 would create £15 billion annually in increased economic output, with phase one accounting for 40 per cent of that benefit (£6 billion per annum).

However, a ‘new mathematical model of human interactions’ predicts that HS2 phase one would create only £3.6 billion annually in increased economic output; less than one per cent of the current output of Birmingham and London.

[HS2 and Crossrail: Scientists predict the economic effect of major rail projects, Simon Levey, Imperial College, 31 July 2015]

[…] Dr [Aaron] Sim carried out the study with Professor Michael Stumpf, also from the Department of Life Sciences, Professor Mauricio Barahona, from the Department of Mathematics, and Professor Sophia Yaliraki, from the Department of Chemistry at Imperial.

They say the findings should be used to help politicians and civic planers to put in place the most efficient, widely beneficial and fairest infrastructure.

.

Written by beleben

July 31, 2015 at 11:20 am

Posted in HS2

HS2 and the Rail Usage Drivers Dataset

leave a comment »

The Government Response to the House of Lords Economic Affairs Committee HS2 report referred to the Rail Usage Drivers Dataset, “a dataset of disaggregate ticket sales data between the years 1994/1995 and 2013/14, for over 20,000 flows and 6 ticket type categories”.

[Department for Transport statement on the Rail Usage Drivers Dataset, July 2015]

This ticket sale information is combined at a disaggregate level with data on possible drivers of rail demand (including population, employment, GVA and households) for the purpose of estimating elasticities using regressions. These elasticities are then used in rail forecasting.

The ticket sales data within RUDD cannot be shared as they are owned by the Train Operating Companies (TOCs) and held by the Department under a duty of confidentiality, in accordance with the National Rail Franchise Terms in place between the Secretary of State and the train operators. The National Rail Franchise Terms can be found published either in or alongside the franchise agreements via the following webpage:

https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/department-for-transport/series/public-register-of-rail-passenger-franchise-agreements .

Under section 41 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000, information held under such a duty is subject to an absolute exemption from disclosure. […]

The Government Response to the House of Lords Economic Affairs Committee report contained aggregate data that was sourced from the RUDD database. These data were released with the agreement of the TOCs concerned for the purpose of the Government’s response to this report.

What isn’t clear, is why the government should have the exclusive right to access and use RUDD data in support of its own favoured policies (such as HS2). For example, statistics from RUDD might also clear up exactly how many of the “long distance” trips on Inter City West Coast, actually are long distance.

Lords Economic Affairs Committee Chairman's letter to the Secretary of State for Transport, page 01

Lords Economic Affairs Committee Chairman's letter to the Secretary of State for Transport, page 02

Lords Economic Affairs Committee Chairman's letter to the Secretary of State for Transport, page 03

Lords Economic Affairs Committee Chairman's letter to the Secretary of State for Transport, page 04

Lords Economic Affairs Committee Chairman's letter to the Secretary of State for Transport, page 05

Lords Economic Affairs Committee Chairman's letter to the Secretary of State for Transport, page 06

Written by beleben

July 29, 2015 at 10:40 am

Posted in HS2

Ignite, accelerate, re-tune

leave a comment »

Greater Birmingham and Solihull local enterprise partnership’s “Getting our people ready for HS2″ report states that the number of HS2 construction jobs is unlikely to greatly exceed 10,000 in any one year.

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 01

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 02

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 03

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 04

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 05

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 06

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 07

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 08

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 09

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 10

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 11

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 12

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 13

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 14

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 15

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 16

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 17

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 18

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 19

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 20

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 21

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 22

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 23

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 24

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 25

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 26

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 27

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 28

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 29

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 30

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 31

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 32

GBSLEP, Getting our people ready for HS2, page 33

Written by beleben

July 27, 2015 at 2:02 pm

Posted in High speed rail, HS2

Tagged with

Opportunities to do free work in Birmingham for Network Rail

with one comment

Birmingham city council Forward newspaper, Summer 2015

Written by beleben

July 27, 2015 at 12:08 pm

Posted in Birmingham

How did we do we do?

leave a comment »

HS2 Ltd, How did-we-do-we-do

Written by beleben

July 27, 2015 at 11:02 am

Extending HS2 to Scotland is “not feasible”

leave a comment »

A joint study by the British and Scottish governments is understood to conclude that extending HS2 to Scotland from northern England is “not feasible”, the Scotsman reported.

'Deal on track to bring fast rail link to Scotland', The Scotsman, 26 July 2015

‘Deal on track to bring fast rail link to Scotland’, The Scotsman, 26 July 2015

SNP press release 'UK Gov must back HS2 for Scotland', 13 Nov 2013

SNP press release ‘UK Gov must back HS2 for Scotland’, 13 Nov 2013

Written by beleben

July 26, 2015 at 10:31 am

Posted in HS2

Tagged with

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 82 other followers