West Coast capacity uncrunched
According to the Department for Transport, the ‘scale of growth’ on the West Coast Main Line between 2008 and 2015 means that “two thirds of the additional inter-city seat capacity provided by the decade-long upgrade is already being utilised”.
What this statement means is not clear, because the total ‘seat capacity provided by the upgrade’, is difficult to establish. A substantial amount of ‘seat capacity’ has come from increasing the number of carriages, or the number of seats on trains, rather than from infrastructure interventions.
- In 2008, the DfT contracted with Alstom for four new Pendolino 11-car trains (44 carriages) and extension of 31 existing units from nine to eleven carriages (62 carriages).
- In 2015, 21 nine-car Pendolinos had one of their 1st class carriages converted to standard class (creating a net increase of 2,100 seats).
What is clear, is that significant capacity potential out of Euston remains untapped (without recourse to ‘old-school’ infrastructure improvements, or ‘Digital Railway’).
Consider Figure 3 of the July 2017 Strategic Case for HS2, which gave the ‘current’ intercity West Coast peak hour (5pm – 6pm) capacity out of Euston as 5,700 seats.
Apparently, seven out of eleven intercity departures in that hour were ‘short trains’, mostly nine-car Pendolinos. The Department for Transport decided against lengthening all Pendolino trainsets to eleven carriages, which suggests that forecast demand did not support the expenditure.
The cost of adding capacity by lengthening short trains, or using higher capacity rolling stock, is, in general, far cheaper than building new lines.
On the Great Western and East Coast lines, the introduction of more space-optimised rolling stock has supported a capacity increase of 28% to 40%, according to IEP train manufacturer Hitachi.
On intercity West Coast, the use of space-optimised rolling stock would allow a ~36% increase, without platform lengthening, or the need for significant lineside interventions.
‘Long distance’ services in 5pm – 6pm peak hour out of Euston (with 11 of 15 fast paths allocated to intercity) |
‘Current’ seats (HS2 July 2017 Strategic Case) |
Seating with 26 metre carriages using full platform length |
|
---|---|---|---|
1 | Birmingham New Street | 470a | 715d |
2 | Birmingham New Street | 470a | 715d |
3 | Glasgow | 591b | 715d |
4 | Glasgow | 591b | 715d |
5 | Holyhead | 512c | 630e |
6 | Lancaster | 470a | 715d |
7 | Liverpool | 591b | 715d |
8 | Liverpool | 470a | 715d |
9 | Manchester | 591b | 715d |
10 | Manchester | 470a | 715d |
11 | Manchester | 470a | 715d |
Total | 5696 | 7780 | |
a = Pendolino 9-car | b = Pendolino 11-car | c = Voyager 2 * 5-car | d = IEP 10-car | e = IEP 2 * 5-car | |||
Figures sourced from the Department for Transport |
You might add the point that if you lengthen 9-car sets to 12 car sets you only have to lengthen the platforms of stations where these 12 car sets stop or are then planned to stop.
hsnorthstart
May 29, 2018 at 4:16 pm